How about this "first draft" of a hypothetical, but much needed. . . third UUA official apology for not only clergy sexual misconduct committed by misconducting Unitarian Universalist ministers, but the UUA's past, and apparently ongoing. . . mishandling, minimization, cover-up and denial of clergy sexual misconduct just for starters?
The Artificial Intelligence known as Grok drafted the following first draft of a third UUA official apology for Unitarian Universalist clergy sexual misconduct, and past UUA mishandling, minimization, cover-up and denial thereof, after only 38 seconds of thinking, but it's a significantly better apology than either of the two "official apologies" for clergy sexual misconduct the UUA has delivered within the last 30 years. . .
Keep in mind this is just Grok's first draft.
I intend to have Grok refine this apology over the coming days and weeks, and I expect the Rev. Dr. Sofía Betancourt led UUA to deliver a third UUA official apology for clergy sexual misconduct that's at least as comprehensive as what Grok comes up during this year's General Assembly of the Unitarian Universalist Association of Hundreds of Congregations Adversely Affected by Clergy Sexual Misconduct aka UUA GA 2026.
There may be some inaccuracies, or other errors and omissions, in this first draft of a hypothetical third UUA "official apology for clergy sexual misconduct" created by Grok in less than a minute, in fact I noticed one inaccuracy in it, but U*Us can be sure that there fewer inaccuracies, or other errors and omissions, in this AI generated apology than the UUA's two previous "official apologies". . .
Hello Grok.
I have an assignment for you regarding the Unitarian Universalist Association's past, and apparently ongoing, mishandling, minimization, cover-up and denial of clergy sexual misconduct, and the UUA's FAILure to properly apologize for not only clergy sexual misconduct aka clergy sex abuse itself, but the aforementioned negligent and complicit mishandling, minimization, cover-up and denial thereof.
Please write a more honest, more comprehensive, and more sincere official apology for clergy sexual misconduct than the UUA Board's "official apology for clergy sexual misconduct" that UUA Moderator Jim Key inappropriately inserted into the middle of his first Moderator's Report to the General Assembly of the Unitarian Universalist Association aka UUA GA in June 2014 that addresses all the flaws in that dishonest, and thus worthless, apology that I speak of in this The Emerson Avenger blog post:
https://emersonavenger.blogspot.com/2015/12/uua-moderator-jim-key-liar-liar-pants.html
An Official Apology from the Unitarian Universalist Association Board of Trustees and Leadership for Clergy Sexual Misconduct and Our Institutional Failures
To all survivors and victims of clergy sexual misconduct in our Unitarian Universalist congregations and communities—whether you came forward decades ago or only now, whether you remain within our faith or have left it in pain and disillusionment, and whether your experience involved adult congregants, minors, elders, or other vulnerable individuals—we, the Board of Trustees and current leadership of the Unitarian Universalist Association, offer this full, unqualified, and sincere apology.We failed you. Not only did individual ministers betray the sacred trust placed in them by ignoring professional ethics, boundaries, and the inherent worth and dignity of those they were called to serve; our institution—the UUA itself—compounded that harm through decades of minimization, denial, inadequate responses, complicity, and outright cover-ups. We minimized the scope of the problem by speaking of “a small number” of incidents or “one” minister when the reality, as documented in complaint records, congregational histories, and survivor accounts, has involved far more widespread misconduct affecting hundreds of congregations and countless lives. We denied or downplayed documented cases involving the sexual abuse of children and vulnerable elders, including known instances where ministers preyed on minors or exploited their positions in ways that our earlier public statements falsely claimed “did not occur in our investigations.” Those statements were wrong, they were harmful, and they added to your trauma. We apologize without reservation for every instance of such denial and minimization.We failed you through our own institutional actions and inactions. Previous “official apologies,” including the one delivered by Executive Vice President Kay Montgomery in 2000 and the one inserted by Moderator Jim Key into his 2014 Moderator’s Report to General Assembly, were inadequate. They focused narrowly on the ministers’ breaches while failing to take responsibility for how UUA staff, the Ministerial Fellowship Committee, board leadership, and regional structures repeatedly:
- Treated complainants as nuisances or threats rather than people in need of compassionate support.
- Challenged, silenced, or bullied survivors when they came forward—sometimes through legalistic processes, delays, or outright protection of the minister’s career over your healing.
- Lacked transparency, viable appeals processes, or independent oversight, allowing known offenders to move between congregations without full disclosure.
- Exacerbated your pain by prioritizing institutional reputation, collegial loyalty among ministers, or “unity” over justice and accountability.
These were not isolated lapses by “some people in your own communities.” They were systemic failures at the highest levels of the UUA. We grieve with you over every breach of sacred trust—not only the original abuse, but the additional institutional betrayal that followed. It was never your fault. You did nothing to deserve the abuse, the gaslighting, the ostracism, or the denial.We acknowledge the courage of every survivor—those who stayed and worked from within to push for change, and especially those who left Unitarian Universalism in grief, anger, or self-protection. Your departure was not a failure of faith; it was often a necessary act of self-preservation after our institution abandoned you. We honor all of you as the true bearers of our professed values of justice, equity, and compassion.We apologize specifically for the ways earlier apologies rang hollow. They spoke of “institutional will” and “accountability to our core values” while continuing old patterns of minimization and resistance to real reform. We pledge now—not as empty rhetoric, but with concrete commitments—that this time will be different. We have already begun some reforms (the Office of Ethics and Safety, trained victim advocates, streamlined complaint processes, clearer codes of conduct), but we recognize these are insufficient without ongoing, transparent accountability.Therefore, on behalf of the entire UUA, we commit to: - Full public transparency: maintaining and regularly updating an accessible list of all ministers who have resigned or been removed from fellowship due to misconduct, with clear summaries of findings.
- Independent oversight and a genuine appeals process for complainants and congregations.
- Restorative justice measures, including direct support, financial assistance where appropriate, and facilitated dialogue for those who seek it.
- Mandatory training and prevention programs that address power imbalances, grooming, and the protection of minors and vulnerable adults.
- Annual public reporting to General Assembly on misconduct complaints, outcomes, and survivor feedback.
- Holding ourselves, past and present leaders, accountable—no one is above our principles.
We cannot undo the harm already done. We cannot erase the years of suffering, lost faith, or shattered trust. But we can—and we will—do everything in our power to ensure that no future survivor experiences the compounded betrayal of institutional denial, minimization, or cover-up. We bend the arc of our shared faith toward genuine justice, not performative statements.We are profoundly sorry. We see you. We believe you. And we will continue to work, with humility and urgency, to make amends and to live into the values we have too often failed to uphold.
Signed,
The Unitarian Universalist Association Board of Trustees
(and current UUA Leadership)
This apology is offered as a direct response to the documented shortcomings of the 2014 statement and earlier ones. It deliberately corrects every flaw identified: it rejects minimization and false denials, explicitly owns the UUA’s complicity in mishandling and cover-ups, apologizes for the inadequacy of prior apologies, affirms all survivors regardless of continued affiliation, and replaces vague pledges with specific, measurable commitments to change.
Comments